For many manufacturers, the automation conversation has shifted. The question is no longer only whether a machine can reduce labor expense. It is whether the business can afford to wait while skilled roles stay open, production teams stretch further and growth opportunities pass by.
According to the Sawbux 2026 Survey of Middle Market Capital Investment, automation investments that once required four- to five-year payback calculations may now pencil at 18 to 24 months when the full cost of unfilled skilled positions is included.
That finding changes the frame. In todayās labor market, the comparison is not always machine versus worker. It may be machine versus vacancy, and that vacancy is rarely free.
Why traditional payback models can fall short
Many ROI models compare the cost of automation with the wages of an employee performing similar work. That can be a useful starting point, but it may understate what happens when the position remains open for months and the operation absorbs the consequences across multiple parts of the business.
The hidden costs behind an open role
An unfilled skilled position can affect overtime, quality, retention and revenue. Current employees may cover the work at premium rates. Rework or scrap may increase when crews are rushed. Recruiting and training costs can rise if overextended employees leave. And the company may delay quotes, decline projects or miss demand because capacity is constrained.
The research indicates that the true annual cost of an unfilled skilled position can run two-and-a-half to four times the posted wage. When that cost is excluded, the payback period may look longer than it is. When it is included, the investment case can look materially different.
How to build a fuller cost-of-vacancy calculation
A stronger automation analysis starts with the companyās own operating reality, not a national average or assumption. Leadership teams can begin by identifying how long critical roles typically remain open and what happens inside the operation during that period.
- Measure vacancy duration. Look at skilled roles that materially affect production and calculate how long they typically remain open.
- Add direct labor pressure. Include overtime premiums, temporary labor and other costs required to keep work moving.
- Estimate quality impact. Capture rework, scrap or inspection costs tied to staffing constraints.
- Include retention effects. Factor in recruiting, training and turnover expenses that may increase when existing teams carry the gap.
- Count capacity limits. Consider delayed quotes, declined work and revenue the company could not pursue because the role was unfilled.
The goal is not to make every automation project pencil. It is to give decisionmakers a more accurate view of the alternative. A disciplined model should still use conservative assumptions for equipment performance, installation timing, training needs and demand. It should also stop treating an open role as if it costs nothing.
Why timing can become a competitive advantage
The difference between studying and approving can compound. A manufacturer that prices vacancies at zero may keep postponing investments that look too expensive on paper. Another that counts the full cost of unfilled roles may approve sooner, capture productivity gains and use one projectās return to help fund the next.
The cost structure gap
Over time, that faster decision cycle can affect more than a single line or machine. It can influence cost structure, capacity, customer responsiveness and the confidence to quote new work.
Questions to ask before making an automation decision
Before moving forward or deciding to wait, leadership teams should pressure-test the investment case with questions such as:
- What does one unfilled skilled role cost each month when overtime, quality issues and lost throughput are included?
- How long do critical production roles typically remain open?
- Which automation projects have been reviewed more than once but not approved?
- Would paybacks change if vacancy costs were treated as operating expense?
- How would the investment affect workforce planning, training and redeployment?
Connect the operating decision to the capital plan
An automation investment is both an operating decision and a capital decision. Equipment may have a lead time. The facility may need changes to power, space or workflow. Financing should be sequenced around installation, training and production ramp-up. Looking at each piece separately can slow a project that otherwise makes financial sense.
At M&T Bank, we help manufacturers look at the full picture, from equipment financing and working capital needs to treasury, risk management and long-term planning. If your team has an automation project that keeps getting studied but not approved, a clearer view of the vacancy math can help turn the conversation from āifā to āhowā with a capital plan tied to the operating outcomes that matter most.
To explore how automation, equipment financing and working capital planning can work together for your business, connect with an M&T Relationship Manager today.
At a glance
- Automation investments that once required four- to five-year payback calculations may now pencil at 18 to 24 months when vacancy costs are fully counted
- Unfilled skilled roles can create costs beyond wages, including overtime, quality drift, turnover pressure and missed revenue opportunities
- A fuller cost-of-vacancy model can help manufacturers decide which projects to approve, which to refine and which to keep on hold